The Best Roof Sealants of 2023 - Top Picks by Bob Vila

2023-01-10 20:31:02 By : Mr. Leo Wu

By James Fitzgerald | Updated Mar 15, 2022 4:09 PM

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Living Roofing Membrane

The Best Roof Sealants of 2023 - Top Picks by Bob Vila

Roofs are designed to withstand an impressive onslaught of extreme weather. While they are designed for rough conditions, the daily exposure to sun, rain, hail, or snow will eventually degrade even the toughest roofs. When this happens, small leaks and penetrations can let in moisture that could result in expensive damage. In some cases, the damage could create the need for a new roof.

By filling any small gaps with roof sealants, DIYers can make protecting and repairing a roof an easier and more affordable task. While some sealants are capable of sealing small and isolated leaks, others can help create a virtually impenetrable barrier against water and sun over an entire roof. If you need to repair your roof or want to extend the life of your roof, keep reading to learn how to choose some of the best roof sealants for a variety of roofing materials.

With so many roof sealants on the market, it can be difficult to choose the best one for your specific needs. In order to narrow down the choices, it helps to review and compare the characteristics of roof sealants. The following considerations can help take the guesswork out of determining the best roof sealant for you.

Roof sealants serve two main purposes: to protect your roof and to repair your roof. Depending on the product, roof sealants can provide a protective seal against moisture and sun exposure and can repair minor leaks before the leak creates serious damage. Although some roof sealants will be effective on virtually any type of roof, most sealants are formulated to work with specific roofing materials.

Roofing materials like asphalt shingles, composite shingles, metal, and rubber have different characteristics that require special considerations. Additionally, whether a roof is flat or slanted also can change what is considered an ideal roof sealant. Finally, whether you’re attempting to repair minor damage or seal an entire roof will impact the type of roof sealant that’s best.

Roof sealants can be divided into two categories: solvent-based and water-based. While solvent-based sealants are highly resilient against the elements, they are generally more expensive, thicker, and harder to apply. Water-based sealants are more affordable and emit fewer odors, but aren’t as weather resilient. They may degrade several years earlier than solvent-based sealants and, therefore, may require more frequent maintenance.

Solvent-based sealants also require the use of a respirator during application to avoid inhaling the solvent fumes, but no mask is required for water-based sealants. Disposing of solvent-based sealants also can be trickier, since they may be considered Household Hazardous Waste (HHW) and need to be disposed of at an appropriate facility. Water-based sealants can be discarded in your household trash bin after the container’s contents have fully air dried.

Within the two main categories, there are five types of roof sealants: acrylic, polyurethane, silicone, rubber, and sealant tape.

The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) established the C1 to C5 certification standards to test and rate a sealant’s ability to withstand specific environmental conditions. A sealant with a C1 certification can only tolerate environments with minimal corrosive elements, like heated buildings with clean atmospheres. A sealant with a C5 certification can tolerate highly corrosive environments, like buildings with high levels of condensation or humidity and high pollution.

The C5 rating can be further divided into C5I for industrial settings, like factories with high humidity and pollution, and C5M for marine settings, like boats and docks exposed to high levels of moisture and salt. Most residential roof sealants won’t have a corrosive resistance rating as high as C5M, but you may want to explore C5M-certified sealant options if your roof is exposed to particularly corrosive conditions.

Every type of roof sealant will offer some protection against water, but not all are capable of producing a completely waterproof membrane. If your main goal is to waterproof your roof, the best sealant types are rubber, silicone, and polyurethane. Each one of these can tolerate heavy rain and pooling water that acrylic sealants and sealant tapes can’t handle as well.

Regardless of the type of sealant used, multiple coats are often required to create a completely waterproof seal over your entire roof. If that’s your intended purpose, it’s important to follow the manufacturer’s directions for creating a waterproof membrane. The exception includes repairing small isolated leaks, where a single coat of most sealants will create a sufficient waterproof barrier.

A roof’s solar reflectivity is the amount of sunlight it’s capable of reflecting, which translates into less heat absorption, which equates to an overall cooler home, reduced air conditioning use, and a lower summer electricity bill. Depending on the sealant’s material and color, adding a layer of roof sealant to a roof can dramatically enhance a roof’s solar reflectivity. Some manufacturers claim that their products can deflect up to 92percent of UV rays.

Rubber, acrylic, silicone, and polyurethane sealants all possess high levels of reflectivity. Along with the sealant’s material composition, the color of the sealant will play a major role in its level of reflectivity. White and light-colored sealants generally possess the highest reflectivity, while black and darker-colored sealants offer the lowest amounts of reflectivity.

A roof sealant’s longevity will vary among manufacturers and the sealant’s material, but most will last between 10 and 20 years. Sealant tapes will usually last this long without any special application process, but the longevity of liquid sealants depends on the thickness of the applied coating. A coating of liquid sealant that’s 30 mils thick can last 10 years longer than a sealant that’s 20 mils thick. Obtaining the proper thickness might require several coats of sealant, and sealant manufacturers will often specify the necessary amount of coats needed to obtain the desired thickness.

Another factor that impacts a roof sealant’s longevity is proper application; a roof sealant that’s applied during cold weather, to a wet or dirty roof, or before rain without adequate time to cure won’t last as long as a correctly applied sealant. Maintaining the performance includes inspecting the roof at least once a year under normal weather conditions and repairing any damage after adverse weather, like heavy rain, snow, and intense sun exposure. Some sealant manufacturers and roofing contractors recommend resealing your roof every 5 years, regardless of its condition, to maximize longevity.

Thicker, solvent-based sealants, like silicone and some rubber sealants, are harder to apply than water-based sealants, like acrylic and some water-based rubber sealants. However, thinner sealants will likely require multiple coats to achieve the necessary thickness, especially when you’re trying to achieve a waterproof seal on your entire roof. Also, thicker sealants may be easier to work with in hot weather, since thin sealants might become too runny to achieve a required thick coat.

Both thick and thin sealants can be applied with a paintbrush or a roller, but with thinner sealants there is the additional option of using a paint sprayer. For isolated repair work, sealants in caulking tubes can more easily access nooks and crannies that would be difficult to reach with a brush, and sealant tapes can be easily applied to the affected area with minimal effort and no additional tools.

After becoming more familiar with the above considerations, you may be ready to start shopping and assess which roof sealant is right for you. To make selecting your sealant even easier, consider some of the following top picks categorized by roof type or need.

Regardless of the roof material or the climate, Liquid Rubber’s sealant is designed to protect it. It’s capable of creating a protective membrane on metal, shingle, or rubber roofs that are either flat or sloped. The sealant creates a rubber coating that is so resilient against standing water that it can be used on the bottom of ponds or gutters, so it should keep a roof protected from any possible amount of rain or snow. This sealant is also UV resistant, so it should also keep a roof protected from aggressive sun exposure.

Its water-based composition makes it incredibly easy to apply with a brush, a roller, or a sprayer, regardless of whether DIYers are repairing isolated leaks or sealing an entire roof. The main disadvantage is that it’s only available in the color black, which limits its solar reflectivity. Liquid Rubber offers a cost-effective and easy-to-use way to avoid expensive roofing repairs in the future.

For those who need to repair only a small section of roofing and don’t want to purchase an entire container of liquid sealant, Gorilla’s 10-foot roll of seal tape might be just what the DIYer needs. It creates a permanent bond that can patch a leak on a variety of roofing materials, including metal, rubber, plastic, and acrylic. While it works best if applied during dry and warm weather, it can be used during cold, hot, humid, and wet weather as well. It can even be applied underwater.

This seal tape is not designed to patch asphalt shingles and may not stick to a roof already treated with a liquid sealant or other water-repellent material. It also creates such a strong bond that attempting to remove this tape after it’s been applied might damage the underlying roofing material. However, with such a wide range of applications at such an affordable price, Gorilla’s seal tape is a solid budget option for patching small sections of damaged roofing.

To prevent small roof leaks from creating expensive damage down the road, Liquid Rubber’s seal tape can quickly and easily seal leaks on a variety of roofing materials. This seal tape comes in 2-inch-wide strips with an adhesive backing that sticks to metal, shingles, and rubber. It can be applied without additional tools and doesn’t require any surface protection or cleanup, unlike other sealant types.

The main disadvantage is that this tape is only useful if users know where the leak is located; otherwise, they may need to use a whole roof treatment to seal visually undetectable leaks. It’s also not UV stable, so it will need an additional layer of liquid sealant to prevent UV degradation. However, using a small section of seal tape to repair minor cracks and holes is an easy and affordable option.

A leaky RV roof can quickly cause extensive damage to the RV’s interior, but Liquid Rubber’s roof coating is specifically formulated to protect against this costly problem. It creates a waterproof and solar-reflective rubber coating over your RV’s rubber or metal roof, which should keep it cool during the summer and protected from weather damage during the entire year.

The rubberized membrane has a high level of flexibility, making it perfectly suited for the constant movement of an RV. One 5-gallon container is enough to provide two to three coats on the roof of an RV that’s up to 30 feet long, so users may only need a single bucket to seal an RV’s entire roof. For users who only need to cover existing leaks or cover vulnerable seams, this sealant is also available in 1-gallon containers. It’s a thin, water-based formula that’s easy to apply, whether using a paintbrush, a roller, or a paint sprayer.

Flat roofs are most susceptible to damage from standing water seeping inside any leaks or cracks. Preventing damage from ponding water on flat roofs is where Rubberseal’s roof seal really stands out. It provides a protective membrane that’s moisture resistant and virtually impenetrable to standing water, while also possessing high solar reflectivity to keep a roof cool and protected all summer long.

Rubberseal offers this sealant in a variety of colors, including white, black, light gray, and dark gray. The color options suit different aesthetic preferences and UV-resistance needs. It’s a thick solvent-based formula, so it’s easy to apply with a paint roller or a brush but it is likely too thick to use with a sprayer. While its thickness might make it harder to apply, it enables users to apply much thicker coats to make a roof as waterproof as possible.

For a roof sealant that’s specifically formulated for metal roofs, this option from Liquid Rubber is hard to beat. A water-based formula that can be applied with a brush, a roller, or a sprayer, it dries into a thick rubber membrane that’s incredibly moisture and UV resistant. The waterproof barrier it creates is resilient against pooling water, so it can be used on flat roofs as well as sloped.

The primary disadvantage is that its use is limited to just a handful of materials, but its specialized nature gives it an extra edge on metal roofs. It also can be used on concrete and wood in addition to metal.

Flashing is an important moisture barrier for your roof, but flashing that’s damaged by storms or age can leave a roof vulnerable to moisture exposure. Just like any other crack or leak in a roof, damage to the roof flashing needs to be repaired to restore the moisture-resistant integrity of a roof. Unfortunately, the gaps created by damaged metal flashing can be difficult to access with many roof sealants. Loctite’s roof flashing sealant was made specifically for this purpose.

As a caulk, it can access the small gaps created by damaged flashing, and the polyurethane sealant restores the flashing’s moisture-resistant function. It also functions as an adhesive, which means it will help close the gap between the flashing and the roof, which further assists in restoring a roof’s weather-resistant properties. This product isn’t the most versatile option on the list, but it serves its purpose of repairing metal roof flashing.

Shoppers looking for a versatile and effective roof sealant should consider Liquid Rubber Waterproof Sealant, which is easy to apply and provides excellent waterproof protection. Alternatively, opt for the Gorilla Waterproof Patch & Seal Tape if you want a quick, budget-friendly fix.

The best roof sealants are easy to apply and provide long-lasting protection to a user’s roof. Our list of recommendations gives shoppers a wide range of options depending on what exactly they are looking for. We did our research to find the best products on the market for specific categories, such as concrete, wood, metal, and slate roof surfaces, in addition to both sloped and flat roofs. Shoppers can find a suitable product that will provide the best protection that suits their specific roof.

When gathering our top picks, we considered the various types of roof sealant available to provide choices for rubber, acrylic, polyurethane, and sealant materials. We also made sure to include plenty of products that boast excellent waterproofing qualities to protect from heavy rainfall and those with reflectivity to help cool homes down during the hot summer months. In addition, we ensured that all our recommendations are easy to apply and can stand up to several years of punishment.

With so many options available, you may still have unanswered questions about roof sealants. Before you start shopping, the answers to some of the most frequently asked questions below may help.

Depending on the thickness of the sealant you choose, you can apply it with a paintbrush, a paint roller, a paint sprayer, or a hand trowel. Some roof sealants come in tubes that are applied with caulk guns.

The drying time for a roof sealant will depend on the sealant’s composition and the weather at the time of application. Most sealants take between 8 and 24 hours to fully dry.

You can usually use a plastic putty knife to remove roof sealant. Just be careful not to damage the underlying roofing material.

Copyright © 2023 Acton Media Inc. All rights reserved.

The Best Roof Sealants of 2023 - Top Picks by Bob Vila

Polymer Walkway Sheet Articles may contain affiliate links which enable us to share in the revenue of any purchases made.